In our time artists have a lot of choices of which genre they will use to tell stories that inspire
them. One common strategy has been to take tales that originate in comic books
or graphic novels and fill them out by using all the resources of the movies.
The Marvel superhero saga dominates film production these days. A somewhat
different example can be seen in the transformation of a popular graphic novel,300, into a film whose artistic roots are unapologetically in comics.
Here we have an example of other artists going the other direction: taking an epic film
and turning it into a book that can be held in one's hands. I would be
interested, sometime down the pike, to know how successful, commercially and artistically,
this project is, how popular it turns out to be with the target audience.
This is certainly a labor of love. It is a faithful
rendering of the 1938 film Alexander Nevsky, one of the most famous products of
Sergei Eisenstein's filmmaking genius. There is no effort to disguise how much
the authors owe to the original version of this story. In fact, quite a bit of
space is devoted to telling the reader about both the historical Alexander
Nevsky and his interpreter, Eisenstein.
Alexander Nevsky was a 13th-century Russian warrior who was
remembered for fighting for Mother Russia against two dangerous enemies, and East
(the Mongol Golden horde) and West (the Teutonic Knights). In the late 1930s
the story seemed both relevant and useful to Eisenstein and the Soviet regime
that employed and often abused him. Japan loomed in one direction, Nazi Germany
in the other. Whatever the facts of the historical Nevsky, he was needed as a
symbol of Russian/Soviet determination in the face of daunting odds.
A story of great courage and heroism defeating treason and
cruelty was right up Eisenstein's alley. If you like your heroes unsullied and
your enemies black as black can be, Eisenstein is your man. The successful
conjuring up of such figures makes the movie unforgettable once you see it. And
the stark contrast is clearly what has inspired the two creators to take on
this remarkable project.
Of course, the success of Nevsky will depend to a very great
extent on its artistic appeal to aficionados of the genre. I'm not really in
that crew. To my eye it looks pretty good. The art combines rich colors, heavy
shading, and the occasional use of odd angles to emphasize some aspect of a
scene.
I have to wonder whether this book will result in a new
audience finding Eisenstein's films.
Funny, I just bought and read this book today. Its a pretty good retelling of the movie although the comedy between the two Russians competing for the girl is both overdone and does not come through very well. Nicely illustrated though.
ReplyDeleteIan